Current:Home > NewsAppeals judges rule against fund used to provide phone services for rural and low-income people-InfoLens
Appeals judges rule against fund used to provide phone services for rural and low-income people
View Date:2024-12-23 16:56:25
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Calling it a “misbegotten tax,” a federal appeals court in New Orleans ruled Wednesday that a method the Federal Communications Commission uses to fund telephone service for rural and low-income people and broadband services for schools and libraries is unconstitutional.
The immediate implications of the 9-7 ruling by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals were unclear. Dissenting judges said it conflicts with three other circuit courts around the nation. The ruling by the full 5th Circuit reverses an earlier ruling by a three-judge panel of the same court and sends the matter back to the FCC for further consideration. The matter could eventually be appealed to the Supreme Court.
At issue in the case is the Universal Service Fund, which the FCC collects from telecommunications providers, who then pass the cost on to their customers.
Programs funded through the USF provide phone service to low-income users and rural healthcare providers and broadband service to schools and libraries. “Each program has a laudable objective,” Judge Andrew Oldham, nominated to the 5th Circuit by former President Donald Trump, wrote for the majority.
Oldham said the USF funding method unconstitutionally delegates congressional taxing authority to the FCC and a private entity tapped by the agency, the Universal Service Administrative Company, to determine how much to charge telecommunications companies. Oldham wrote that “the combination of Congress’s broad delegation to FCC and FCC’s subdelegation to private entities certainly amounts to a constitutional violation.”
Judge Carl Stewart, nominated to the court by former President Bill Clinton, was among 5th Circuit judges writing strong dissents, saying the opinion conflicts with three other circuit courts, rejects precedents, “blurs the distinction between taxes and fees,” and creates new doctrine.
The Universal Service Administrative Company referred a request for comment to the FCC, which did not immediately respond to phone and emailed queries.
veryGood! (69)
Related
- Jury awards Abu Ghraib detainees $42 million, holds contractor responsible
- Remembering the Volkswagen Beetle: When we said bye-bye to the VW Bug for the last time
- Penn State-West Virginia weather updates: Weather delay called after lightning at season opener
- Using a living trust to pass down an inheritance has a hidden benefit that everyone should know about
- Ford agrees to pay up to $165 million penalty to US government for moving too slowly on recalls
- Caitlin Clark returns to action: How to watch Fever vs. Wings on Sunday
- Drew Barrymore reflects on her Playboy cover in 'vulnerable' essay
- Gaudreau’s wife thanks him for ‘the best years of my life’ in Instagram tribute to fallen NHL player
- Justine Bateman feels like she can breathe again in 'new era' after Trump win
- Most major retailers and grocers will be open on Labor Day. Costco and your bank will be closed
Ranking
- The Masked Singer's Ice King Might Be a Jonas Brother
- Small plane carrying at least 2 people crashes into townhomes near Portland, engulfs home in flames
- Tennessee football fan gets into argument with wife live during Vols postgame radio show
- Adele Announces Lengthy Hiatus From Music After Las Vegas Residency Ends
- Rachael Ray Details Getting Bashed Over Decision to Not Have Kids
- Trump issues statement from Gold Star families defending Arlington Cemetery visit and ripping Harris
- Four Downs and a Bracket: Clemson is not as far from College Football Playoff as you think
- Defending champion Coco Gauff loses in the U.S. Open’s fourth round to Emma Navarro
Recommendation
-
Diamond Sports Group can emerge out of bankruptcy after having reorganization plan approved
-
School is no place for cellphones, and some states are cracking down
-
Brad Pitt and Girlfriend Ines de Ramon Make Red Carpet Debut at Venice International Film Festival
-
Texas A&M vs Notre Dame score today: Fighting Irish come away with Week 1 win at Aggies
-
Avril Lavigne’s Ex Mod Sun Is Dating Love Is Blind Star Brittany Wisniewski, Debuts Romance With a Kiss
-
49ers rookie Ricky Pearsall shot in attempted robbery in San Francisco
-
Doctor charged in Matthew Perry's death released on $50,000 bond, expected to plead guilty
-
How to know if your kid is having 'fun' in sports? Andre Agassi has advice